The Catskills have evolved from rustic cabins to a serious destination for discerning travelers. Whether you're planning a ski weekend, a fall foliage escape, or a summer golf getaway, where you stay defines the experience.
We spent months researching, visiting, and comparing the best accommodations across the Northern Catskills and Hudson Valley. Here's our definitive ranking for 2026.
1. Ascent 110 at Windham — The Clear Winner
If you're traveling with a group, nothing else comes close. This seven-bedroom estate sits minutes from Windham Mountain Club and offers amenities you won't find anywhere else in the region:
- 7 bedrooms, 12 beds, sleeps 18
- Private hot tub with mountain views
- Game room with pool table, poker, and arcade
- Portable pickleball net for the patio
- Home gym and EV charger
- 2,700 sq ft of outdoor patio space
- Fireplace and fire pit
- Full gourmet kitchen
What sets Ascent 110 apart isn't just the space — it's the thoughtfulness. Every detail, from the heated bathroom floors to the ski storage with boot warmers, shows someone actually skis and understands what a mountain house should be.
**Best for:** Groups of 8-16, ski trips, weddings, corporate retreats **Rate:** $350-550/night (entire house) **Book:** [Check availability](/book)
---
2. The DeBruce — Livingston Manor
A refined boutique hotel on 600 acres with a Michelin-recommended restaurant. The DeBruce is romantic, intimate, and absolutely stunning. Each room has a fireplace, and the property includes a private river for fly fishing.
**Best for:** Couples, romantic getaways, food lovers **Rate:** $400-700/night **Note:** Only 14 rooms — book well in advance
---
3. Scribner's Catskill Lodge — Hunter
A hip, design-forward lodge at the base of Hunter Mountain. The aesthetic is Scandinavian-meets-Adirondack, and the on-site restaurant is excellent. The lodge hosts regular events — live music, yoga, wine tastings.
**Best for:** Young professionals, design enthusiasts, social travelers **Rate:** $250-450/night **Note:** Can get lively on weekends — not for those seeking solitude
---
4. Eastwind Hotel & Bar — Windham
A boutique hotel with a distinctly Nordic vibe. The Lushna cabins are Instagram-famous for good reason — floor-to-ceiling windows, wood-burning stoves, and minimalist design. The on-site bar is a local favorite.
**Best for:** Couples, design lovers, Instagram moments **Rate:** $300-500/night **Note:** Lushna cabins book months ahead for peak season
---
5. The Arnold House — Livingston Manor
A renovated 1850s boarding house with a tavern, spa, and pool. The Arnold House has a cozy, communal feel — guests gather in the tavern for dinner and drinks. The rooms are comfortable but not luxurious.
**Best for:** Solo travelers, friend groups, casual getaways **Rate:** $200-350/night **Note:** Shared spaces mean less privacy
---
6. Hotel Lilien — Tannersville
A beautifully restored 1890s Victorian mansion with 18 rooms. The design is maximalist and theatrical — velvet, wallpaper, antique furniture. The restaurant is excellent, and the location is convenient to Hunter and Windham.
**Best for:** Design lovers, couples, special occasions **Rate:** $300-500/night **Note:** Some rooms are small — request an upgrade
---
7. The Graham & Co. — Phoenicia
A no-frills motel reinvented for the Instagram generation. Clean, simple, and affordable with a great location near Phoenicia Diner and tubing. The pool is a summer highlight.
**Best for:** Budget travelers, casual weekends, young groups **Rate:** $150-250/night **Note:** Basic amenities — this is a motel, not a resort
---
8. Foxfire Mountain House — Mount Tremper
A bohemian retreat with Moroccan-inspired decor, a saltwater pool, and 10 acres of gardens. The communal dinners are legendary, and the vibe is distinctly artistic and free-spirited.
**Best for:** Creatives, spiritual seekers, solo travelers **Rate:** $250-400/night **Note:** Communal meals mean set schedules — not for independent travelers
---
9. Hunter Mountain Lodges — Hunter
Ski-in/ski-out convenience at Hunter Mountain. These condos and townhouses are functional, not fancy, but the location is unbeatable for skiers who want first tracks.
**Best for:** Skiers, families with young kids, convenience seekers **Rate:** $200-400/night **Note:** Dated interiors — you're paying for location
---
10. Airbnb Cabins — Various
The Catskills have thousands of Airbnb options, from $100/night rustic cabins to $800/night luxury homes. Quality varies wildly — read reviews carefully and verify amenities.
**Best for:** Budget flexibility, unique finds, repeat visitors **Rate:** $100-800/night **Note:** Inconsistent quality — photos can be misleading
---
The Verdict
For groups of 8 or more, Ascent 110 is the obvious choice — no hotel or rental comes close in terms of space, amenities, and value per person. For couples, The DeBruce or Eastwind offer more intimacy. For budget travelers, The Graham & Co. or a well-vetted Airbnb are solid options.
The Catskills have something for every traveler. The question is: what kind of experience are you looking for?
Tags
Stay at Ascent 110
Live availability and prices — 5% less than Airbnb when you book direct. Open full booking page
